The situation was that a shade greener bought three actions against the OP and each one of them for one reason or another were dismissed by the court.   In 2018 the OP for that this was the end of the matter and so was surprised that a Shade Greener went ahead on exactly the same facts to bring a new action. In May 2019 they issued another claim which reached the OP.   The facts in the claim form were pretty well the same as has already been discussed here and so I don't