Jump to content


  • Tweets

  • Posts

    • Where was the help for the environment, social care, renters, and to cover the future costs of Covid? View the full article
    • Hi All, I have received a parking ticket as RK (thats registered keeper right?) for overstaying by 16 mins in a well known wholesalers car park in Liverpool. I read some very confusing (and sometimes contradictory information on several sites) on how to deal with this. I followed the instructions to firstly challenge the validity of their claim. I wrote to them (no response) and emailed them. I had to guess at the email address becuase they provide only the registered office address or a 'claim line', which if i had contacted them on that, would have been agreeing to their idea of us having a contract in the first place (right?). So i eventually got the admin email and sent it there, stating that i had already written to them with no response. I got a response saying that they do not respond to correspondence at that address and i should either write to them (already did) or contact via the appeals line or appeals email (again with the acknowledgement that its an appeal i need, rather than straight up confirmation). I asked in at the wholesalers customer/ member services in store about the car park ownership and they informed me it was a consistent problem and they didnt know the owner. I have contacted the head office in Herts for the information. (Customer services/ member services/ online services & complaints) for the information regarding ownership of carpark and the contract of agreement between them and the CE parking management with no luck. I received no further correspondence and therefore assumed that they had dropped their spurious claims. They acknowledged my letter with: "Response from representation team -  We refer to your recent correspondance. We accept for you to pay the original reduced sum of £100. The Parking Charge Notice has been passed to a debt recovery agenct. All further enquiries, including payments, must be directed to them. Please follow the instruction on the correspondence you have received." I received nothing else until I receive a Northampton county court business service court claim. The amount is now in the hundreds (£274). I have acknowledged and sent back the form with nothing else written on it. So now i have another week or so to mount my defence. I dont know anyone who speaks 'legalese' and frankly its giving me sleepless nights. Incidentally, at the time of the alleged 'contravention' there was a bout of sudden severe weather which was 'waited out' inside the wholesalers porch by several members and their children because the soft furnishings and electricals (for example) bought in store would have been destroyed by the downpour. Further investigation into the owner of the Civil Enforcement ltd has shown me that they are owned by CCP parking, who are in turn owned by Qa Nominees and are owned by people exposed in the Panama Papers scandal. I am feeling like im a tiny part of a very big scam here, one that DVLA are profiting from. Under advisement, I have written a complaint to the wholesalers complaining about being treated so shoddily as a member. Under advisement, I have also written to CE ltd requesting a Subject Access Request. But I really dont understand the process or what steps to take now.
    • Hi Anney,   When you get the SAR, can you give us some more detailed info info like loan amount, date taken out, last pay't made, balance remaining,.
    • Also what reason do Vodafone give for the sudden increase in the bill In Jan 16? Why no ETFs in that note there?   I don't think you are getting the whole picture.
    • Just out of interest, did Ryanair’s solicitors mention the bird strike ruling in their defence?   Also, were they claiming £350 as the cost of the defence?   Regards.
  • Our picks

    • I sent in the bailiffs to the BBC. They collected £350. It made me smile.
        • Haha
        • Like
    • Hi @BankFodder
      Sorry for only updating you now, but after your guidance with submitting the claim it was pretty straight forward and I didn't want to unnecessarily waste your time. Especially with this guide you wrote here, so many thanks for that
      So I issued the claim on day 15 and they requested more time to respond.
      They took until the last day to respond and denied the claim, unsurprisingly saying my contract was with Packlink and not with them.
       
      I opted for mediation, and it played out very similarly to other people's experiences.
       
      In the first call I outlined my case, and I referred to the Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999 as the reason to why I do in fact have a contract with them. 
       
      In the second call the mediator came back with an offer of the full amount of the phone and postage £146.93, but not the court costs. I said I was not willing to accept this and the mediator came across as a bit irritated that I would not accept this and said I should be flexible. I insisted that the law was on my side and I was willing to take them to court. The mediator went back to Hermes with what I said.
       
      In the third call the mediator said that they would offer the full amount. However, he said that Hermes still thought that I should have taken the case against Packlink instead, and that they would try to recover the court costs themselves from Packlink.
       
      To be fair to them, if Packlink wasn't based in Spain I would've made the claim against them instead. But since they are overseas and the law lets me take action against Hermes directly, it's the best way of trying to recover the money.
       
      So this is a great win. Thank you so much for your help and all of the resources available on this site. It has helped me so much especially as someone who does not know anything about making money claims.
       
      Many thanks, stay safe and have a good Christmas!
       
       
        • Thanks
    • Hermes and mediation hints. https://www.consumeractiongroup.co.uk/topic/428981-hermes-and-mediation-hints/&do=findComment&comment=5080003
      • 1 reply
    • Natwest Bank Transfer Fraud Call HMRC Please help. https://www.consumeractiongroup.co.uk/topic/428951-natwest-bank-transfer-fraud-call-hmrc-please-help/&do=findComment&comment=5079786
      • 33 replies

Shoplifting charge from supermarket, please comment with advice, thank you.


Please note that this topic has not had any new posts for the last 2891 days.

If you are trying to post a different story then you should start your own new thread. Posting on this thread is likely to mean that you won't get the help and advice that you need.

If you are trying to post information which is relevant to the story in this thread then please flag it up to the site team and they will allow you to post.

Thank you

Recommended Posts

Hi there readers, just wanted to start this with a plea; please do not judge me by what you are about to read. I am fully aware of how it sounds, plus after reading other's threads, I too have jumped to conclusions.

 

My background is that I am a full time student, this normally means 'poor' or 'desperate for food', however, unlucky for me yet good for my finances, I was left with considerable inheritance. I am 22 years old and consider myself to be well brought up and a well dressed, middle class girl. (sorry if that sounds ridiculous, just want you to know the facts)

 

I am writing this to ask for advice, I would be extremely grateful for any information you could bring to my attention. I'l try to ignore the negativity and judgement.

 

It begins with me being in a large local supermarket, eg Tesco/ Sainsburys, where I have done all my shopping for the last two years of uni. My bill normally comes in at around £40, £8 of which is spent on bottled water. This time, I was shopping with a friend, sharing a trolly, they were to use my self service check out after me. However, they went of to find an item they had forgotten whilst I was scanning through my shopping. I paid for my items yet still saw no return of my friend. I was holding my receipt and checking for error as it was lower than I expected (obviously a good thing but I wanted to be sure). Whilst doing this task along with slowly moving my trolly out of other customer's way, I was phoning my friend. During this 1/ 2 minutes, I had moved around 100 yards, approaching the exit, I intended to put my shopping into the car and help my friend with her shopping. I was still multi tasking at this point, looking at my receipt, just as I crossed the exit, I noticed why my bill was low, my water hadn't scanned. It's water and this is England, not exactly crime of the century simply not bothering about it, yet I done the decent thing and turn back to the store.

 

As I made this moral decision, a man in dark uniform asked me to follow him, I mentioned I was going in to sort out my receipt. Then as we walked in, a worker exclaimed, "ahh you've finally got her". To be honest, I thought i'd walked into another person's horror story. When in the back room of the store, the extremely nasty security guard started accusing me of crimes I was unaware of. Apparently my Method of action, or system, (something that sounds like a plan) was that I leave my water in the trolly on purpose. I don't know if they realise you are suppose to and then peel off the tag to scan, that is the way the water company have designed it to be, to be convenient for customers.

 

 

For at least two years, I have been shopping here weekly, regularly purchasing this water. That means I have bought about £832 worth of this product from them!! (8x104) Except the last two shopping occasions I have 'stolen' this item from them. Water, I apparently stole water?!

 

Yes I totally agree, shoplifting is wrong, just, give people a chance before jumping down their throats and ruining their lives. Maybe let someone explain! This isn't a third world country, I have no reason to steal water.

 

 

On from that, this is the part in which I feel the judgement beginning to brew, as even I know it looks extremely dishonest. When they checked my items, re scanning them all, there were a number of items that I had not scanned correctly. However, this was a God's honest mistake. I had forgotten to scan through my butter, blueberries and some bacon. Not exactly champagne or a weapon, something one may do purposely. I had scanned through all my other shopping, these items had just been caught up under my bags and crates of water (not an act I'd do purposely as squashed butter and blueberries aren't sought after.) My friend had also left a couple of items in there which there was no way of me seeing.

 

I had scanned through my items, using a self service machine I believed to be in working order. Yet when I come to see my receipt, things had been scanned through as items I had not purchased. Eg, cranberry juices, I had none of these in my trolly! There was obviously issues with the till. Can I please ask if there is a way I can prove the fault?

 

I did not have the intent to enter the store and remove their goods without paying. Any advice you can offer me with this situation would be grate, please refrain from calling me a thief, I already feel extremely scared and stupid. My future is the most important part of my life, my career will be saving millions of lives through medical research. A criminal record could disrupt my career path and future medical profession.

 

Thank you for taking the time to read this.

 

Kind regards, from a very worried girl.x

Sorry for making this soo long!

Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi there readers, just wanted to start this with a plea; please do not judge me by what you are about to read. I am fully aware of how it sounds, plus after reading other's threads, I too have jumped to conclusions.

 

My background is that I am a full time student, this normally means 'poor' or 'desperate for food', however, unlucky for me yet good for my finances, I was left with considerable inheritance. I am 22 years old and consider myself to be well brought up and a well dressed, middle class girl. (sorry if that sounds ridiculous, just want you to know the facts)

 

I am writing this to ask for advice, I would be extremely grateful for any information you could bring to my attention. I'l try to ignore the negativity and judgement.

 

It begins with me being in a large local supermarket, eg Tesco/ Sainsburys, where I have done all my shopping for the last two years of uni. My bill normally comes in at around £40, £8 of which is spent on bottled water. This time, I was shopping with a friend, sharing a trolly, they were to use my self service check out after me. However, they went of to find an item they had forgotten whilst I was scanning through my shopping. I paid for my items yet still saw no return of my friend. I was holding my receipt and checking for error as it was lower than I expected (obviously a good thing but I wanted to be sure). Whilst doing this task along with slowly moving my trolly out of other customer's way, I was phoning my friend. During this 1/ 2 minutes, I had moved around 100 yards, approaching the exit, I intended to put my shopping into the car and help my friend with her shopping. I was still multi tasking at this point, looking at my receipt, just as I crossed the exit, I noticed why my bill was low, my water hadn't scanned. It's water and this is England, not exactly crime of the century simply not bothering about it, yet I done the decent thing and turn back to the store.

 

As I made this moral decision, a man in dark uniform asked me to follow him, I mentioned I was going in to sort out my receipt. Then as we walked in, a worker exclaimed, "ahh you've finally got her". To be honest, I thought i'd walked into another person's horror story. When in the back room of the store, the extremely nasty security guard started accusing me of crimes I was unaware of. Apparently my Method of action, or system, (something that sounds like a plan) was that I leave my water in the trolly on purpose. I don't know if they realise you are suppose to and then peel off the tag to scan, that is the way the water company have designed it to be, to be convenient for customers.

 

 

For at least two years, I have been shopping here weekly, regularly purchasing this water. That means I have bought about £832 worth of this product from them!! (8x104) Except the last two shopping occasions I have 'stolen' this item from them. Water, I apparently stole water?!

 

Yes I totally agree, shoplifting is wrong, just, give people a chance before jumping down their throats and ruining their lives. Maybe let someone explain! This isn't a third world country, I have no reason to steal water.

 

 

On from that, this is the part in which I feel the judgement beginning to brew, as even I know it looks extremely dishonest. When they checked my items, re scanning them all, there were a number of items that I had not scanned correctly. However, this was a God's honest mistake. I had forgotten to scan through my butter, blueberries and some bacon. Not exactly champagne or a weapon, something one may do purposely. I had scanned through all my other shopping, these items had just been caught up under my bags and crates of water (not an act I'd do purposely as squashed butter and blueberries aren't sought after.) My friend had also left a couple of items in there which there was no way of me seeing.

 

I had scanned through my items, using a self service machine I believed to be in working order. Yet when I come to see my receipt, things had been scanned through as items I had not purchased. Eg, cranberry juices, I had none of these in my trolly! There was obviously issues with the till. Can I please ask if there is a way I can prove the fault?

 

I did not have the intent to enter the store and remove their goods without paying. Any advice you can offer me with this situation would be grate, please refrain from calling me a thief, I already feel extremely scared and stupid. My future is the most important part of my life, my career will be saving millions of lives through medical research. A criminal record could disrupt my career path and future medical profession.

 

Thank you for taking the time to read this.

 

Kind regards, from a very worried girl.x

Sorry for making this soo long!

 

Were the police called?

If so were you given a Penalty Notice for Disorder (PND / fixed penalty 'fine')?

If the police were called & you weren't given a PND, were you arrested by the police?

 

As for : "my career will be saving millions of lives through medical research" : 'youthful enthusiasm' or 'lacks insight'?

How many medical researchers can you name who have provably "saved millions"?

Link to post
Share on other sites
You take a a lawyer's help dear. They will better help you out of this mess.

 

Hello SillyOne.

 

I don't think you're at the stage of needing a lawyer. Maybe you could let us know the answer to Bazza's question please? The guys should be along later.

 

My best, HB

Illegitimi non carborundum

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Hello SillyOne.

 

I don't think you're at the stage of needing a lawyer. Maybe you could let us know the answer to Bazza's question please? The guys should be along later.

 

My best, HB

 

Agreed, HB : they MIGHT need a lawyer, but might not.

If they answer my queries about the police, CAG'ers will have a better idea of if they are facing a record of the incident on the Police National Computer (PNC), which in turn impacts on if they'll likely need a lawyer.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi all, thank you for your replies. Really appreciate people trying to help.

 

To answer your questions; when I was in the back room, a police officer was called straight away without me saying anything or being given a chance.

 

When the officer arrived, he did try to reason with the security guard and say it was all just a misunderstanding, however, the security seemed to have a vendetta against me. He began to list many other actions of theft I had 'committed', although I hadn't even been in the country at some of the times, making it clear to me that this man was not going to accept any apology. He took the police officer to another room and showed him CCTV footage. The officer, who was surprising kind, told the security that some of the 'video evidence' was absurd and obviously not me. You can imagine how grateful I was for some support at this time.

 

Two of recordings, matched up with the use of my loyalty card. The computer stated that no water had been paid for on two occasions when the cctv showed that it was amongst my shopping. This is part of my regular shopping, just a stupid mistake I had made and would of definitely paid for. As I have said before, I've spent hundreds of pounds on this relatively cheap product in the past. However, that is not how the law works, I understand that. That is why, when I noticed there was no water on my receipt, I went back to pay for it.

 

Sorry for this being such a long account, I am not good at summarising!

 

When arrested and taken into a cell, I agreed to a solicitor as I knew I had landed into a complete mess. After 23 and a 1/2 hours in the cell, I was finally able to speak to my solicitor. Who was very annoyed as he had been free to speak to me all day, they had just tried to keep us apart. I do not know where the officer who arrested me had gone, he was no longer involved, a new kid was on the case that did not want to make the process simple.

 

After relaying what had happened to my appointed solicitor, he said I would be able to get a caution as it was not a serious crime at all and they should realise it was just a mistake. I thought about seeing if my friend would say about what she had left in the trolly so I would not be blamed for that, however, I did not want to drag her name into any kind of mess. At this point, I wish we didn't trolly share!!

 

Whilst being interviewed, I stated that on two of the occasions, it was me in the cctv. I had left the store without paying, however I stated that this was not through the act of theft, it was a misunderstanding and not something I would ever do. I did not want to state I had been dishonest as I had not purposely done this. This is something I came to regret..

 

Apparently if I had admitted guilt, I would of got off with a caution. Wish my rubbish solicitor had told me that. Although it was a mistake, I would of much rather said I had intently done it, just to be out of that situation. They had taken my fingerprints, however, a caution would not of caused disruption to my future. I have a court date for next week. They seemed to just ignore what I said about the self service machine. These are always breaking and it was clear, from not only the cctv but from the fact it was impossible to of 'stolen' items after scanning them through, that the machine had mixed products. There were items on my receipt I had not even selected nor put into my trolly. Surely, as a solicitor, you would focus on this part. When asking for advice, my solicitor said that was not how it worked. Apparently I have to come to a decision myself, all he does is represent me. I'm the type of person who listens to all advice so was shocked by this as I felt I needed his knowledge and degree in law!

 

If you any of you lovely helpful people have any advice, I would greatly welcome it.

 

Thank you.x

 

 

p.s. 'BazzaS' sorry I had not stated all the details, hope what I have replied with makes the situation clearer. As for the medical research, it is in neurodegenerative disease research, something that within the next decade will become an epidemic. Research into Alzheimer's disease is currently making breakthroughs and all researchers are needed. This is something I am passionate about, why I have chosen to continue in education. Hopefully my utter stupidity on the listed occasions will not affect my future in this field of research :(

Link to post
Share on other sites

A formal caution involves an admission of guilt, and leaves you with the same record for CRB/DBS purposes as a conviction, so I'm not sure "a caution would not of caused disruption to my future" is correct advice, even if you have been told this.

 

While you may wish to make the point that the self-service machine can make errors, in the end the court will look at if you took the water and had not paid (which appears not in contention) but then the key issue "was there intent to permanently deprive "

 

It may be against you if there is CCTV of a prior episode.

You say you had decided to go back and pay this time round when you realised : were you actually headed back when stopped and might there be CCTV to demonstrate that?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Although you mention that stealing water isn't the theft of the century it is still theft?

 

If it's an honest mistake then don't beat yourself up about it. One thing that i find strange is that you said you took a trolley through the self checkout? I don't mean to be negative but the trolleys aren't that deep and if you had a lot of items then surely you would've gone through the normal checkout?

Link to post
Share on other sites

sorry but you have made the mistake of not paying on at least two other occasions? once ok but anymore is becoming a habit you would be extra vigilent if you had made a mistake once to avoid doing it again,

If I have been of any help, please click on my star and let me know, thank you.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Some of the supermarkets now have conveyor self service checkouts. Don't know if you still get those awful voice messages i.e "Unexpected item" etc so you can use trollies at them. If it was the older style, did you not get the "Unexpected" bit when you scanned the items and put them on the scales/bagging area ,or did you say you were using your own bags? Either way you need to be more vigilant as assisted blonde says.

Link to post
Share on other sites

From a legal point of view although of the machine wasnt working properly it showed items that i didnt actually have etc etc there is no getting away from the fact that you actually had unscaned items in your trolly and you had made no attempt to scan them, whether you knew they were there or not.

If I have been of any help, please click on my star and let me know, thank you.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Recently Browsing   0 Caggers

    No registered users viewing this page.


  • Have we helped you ...?


×
×
  • Create New...