Morgan Stanley - Three PPI and Three interest one account !!

[AllanLyn]

I have the statements for a Morgan Stanley Dean Witter credit card from 2003 - 2007.

 

Each month shows they took out three separate amounts for PPI and three separate amounts for interest. I have checked with Morgan Stanley and they say Barclay's are now responsible for the account.

 

What is the best way to get this account sorted out, claim the PPI and the overcharged interest?

 

Which claim forms should I use? Any help would be appreciated.

[dx100uk]

http://www.consumeractiongroup.co.uk/forum/showthread.php?330996-Latest-Spreadsheets-PPI-Claims-and-Charges-Claims-Dec-2011

 

http://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/publications/technical_notes/ppi.html

 

and a covering letter

 

cheeky beggars 3 int charges!!

 

dx

[AllanLyn]

Thanks for the info DX I will keep this thread informed....

[AllanLyn]

I have just looked at spread sheets available - should i be completing CISheet v101.xls ??

 

Should I also use this form for claiming the interest?

 

I guess this problem is a bit different to the usual claim and I am not sure about the way to go about it.

[dx100uk]

yes areed

 

canyou scan up one of the statement showing this please:

 

as a picture[jpg] file

or convert them to .PDF

ENSURE:remove all pers info inc barcodes etc using paint program

but leave all figures and dates.

 

goto one of the many free online pdf converter websites

it would be better to upload a multipage pdf

than many single ones

or if you have PDF as an installed printer drive use that

or use word and save as pdf

open a new msg box here

hit go advanced below the msg box

hit manage attachments below that box

hit the add files button on the top right

hit select files, navigate to your file on your pc

hit upload files

NB:you can set where it goes in the post by hitting insert inline.

then hit reply button

dx

[AllanLyn]

Scanner is not working but i can easily type the info - will do asap

[AllanLyn]

The following is as per one of the statements:

 

COPY STATEMENT

ACCOUNT NUMBER XXXXXXX

CUSTOMER NAME XXXXXXX XXXX

ADDRESS XXXXXXX

 

STMT DATE 21/05/2003 CREDIT £XXXX CASH LIMIT £ XXXX

CASH AVAIL£ XXX CREDIT AVAIL £XXXX CASH LIMIT £XXXX

MIN PAYMT £XXX PMT DUE 15/06/2003

 

12/05/2003 PAYMENT VIA BGC - THANKYOU £ 102.00

 

12/05/2003 INTEREST £24.63

 

12/05/2003 INTEREST £18.80

 

12/05/2003 INTEREST £18.99

 

12/05/2003 PAYMENT PROTECTION PLAN £15.14

 

12/05/2003 PAYMENT PROTECTION PLAN £11.59

 

12/05/2003 PAYMENT PROTECTION PLAN £ 8.81

[dx100uk]

bal for that month?

 

dx

[AllanLyn]

£5041.51 - sorry DX the interest and PPI dates should be 21/05/2003

[dx100uk]

ok me or ims will look at this later.

 

dx

[AllanLyn]

Thanks DX

[AllanLyn]

Hi DX can you or IM take a look at this for me please ... thanks

[ims21]

Hi

 

It looks like it could be three rates for three different things

 

1 Purchases i.e. normal transactions

 

2 Cash Advances

 

3 Balance transfer rate

 

Any of this ring any bells?

[AllanLyn]

I think this was a card that I got and transferred the balance from another card

- the very first statement on 12/5/03 shows the credit limit was £5500 and current balance was £5041.51.

 

All of the monthly statements between 2003 and 2007 other than 21/7/03 look exactly the same as the example above

the only difference on the 21/07/03 statement are three cash advances totalling £500.

I had no purchases on any statement.

 

I dont understand why the very first statement (above) should show three interest and three PPI and for them to continue till 2007.

 

Having said all of the above can you advise what sort of claim I should put in and as there are three ppi how do I go about it? Sorry to be a pain but I just dont know how to approach it .... thanks Allan

Edited April 21, 2012 by AllanLyn
added more info

[ims21]

Hi

 

Right I think we can take a good stab at this.

 

If the copy statements show the rates of interest then work out what the average rate is. If the rate is shown as a monthly rate then work out the average of the monthly rate and pop that rate into this spreadsheet and it will work out the APR based on a monthly rate.

 

MonthlyToAPR.xls

 

You will need the APR to enter into the main spreadsheet which is attached below.

 

If you don't have the rates on the copy statements you are going to have to have a stab at working it out. Add up the total interest you have been charged for the month. Divide it by the total opening balance on the statement and multiply the result by 100. Make a note of that percentage figure. Do the same for a random sample of six statements and you can then work out the average rate.

 

Pop that into the spreadsheet above to give the estimated APR and use that in the main spreadsheet.

 

Use the main spreadsheet below to reconstruct the account. Follow the instructions in the sheet.

 

If the balance is split into three items, add them together to give on figure and use that where the reference in the sheet is to the balance figure.

 

Add up the total transactions for the month including PPI, Interest, cash withdrawals and anything else and use that figure as the total spend for the month.

 

Enter the amount repaid for the month.

 

Where it asks for the PPI amount, add up the three charges for PPI and enter those as one figure.

 

When complete you will have the best estimate of a reconstructed account and the potential PPI award will be shown in the spreadsheet.

 

Go along to the fos website and grab a copy of the consumer questionnaire and complete it.

 

Send a copy of the spreadsheet and consumer questionnaire to Barclays together with a brief letter requiring refund.

 

They will have 8 weeks to investigate and give you a final decision before you can pass it to fos to deal with.

 

FosRunningPPI v101.xls

 

ims

[dx100uk]

well you can merge the PPI and use CIsheet thats for sure

or p'haps the FOSRUNNINGCI sheet.

 

as for the interests

well your PPI claim will be at the [highest] rate you can find on the statements.

 

dx

[AllanLyn]

Thanks IMX and DX

I have all the statements and a very poor copy of the application form and I think the APR reads 18.9%. I will get into this over the weekend and get the figures into the spreadsheet.

 

I will keep you informed and get back to you if I have problems.... both of you thank you so much for your time and interest in my problem.

 

AllanLyn

[ims21]

No worries

 

we will always help where we can. Just shout here.

 

ims