Jump to content

EdithL

Registered Users

Change your profile picture
  • Content Count

    13
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

1 Neutral

About EdithL

  • Rank
    Basic Account Holder
  1. It is their own brand sofas Hart of house, and both have different batch numbers, so it not one batch problem, I educated them that as per Consumer Act replacement need to be free from the manufacturing faults identified in the reports if it will develop the same problem I will be eligible for another replacement, and there is no limit of replacement that I will be eligible for, so if it will happen again and again they will need to give me replacement every time
  2. Hello, I finally received written report, 3 manufacturing faults identified with each sofa, Argos agreed to send replacement and issued full refund for the report £270 and gift voucher as a"gesture of goodwill". They also said that they will investigate internally why Castelan provided false information in their report. The reason for my 16 months old sofas was wrongly sealed leather, therefore it peeled off, it was not repairable, the report says they would need to strip all the leather and replace it and replace all the fillings in cushions, arm rests etc. It also stated that this manufacturing fault will get worse and immediate action is required from retailer
  3. Hi Slick, I am very happy with the inspection and I am happy to recommend the company even before they will issue me the report, they took their time about 1,5 hrs to inspect the sofas inch by inch. The company is called Furniture Reports, It doesn't let me to post the links but they were on the TV on the Rip off Britain show. The copy of Castelan report that I have received from Argos is basically few lines and based on assumptions only as there was no evidence of contamination on the sofa, also I was told during the inspection yesterday that both sofas were not sealed properly and both will be pealing off, something like this is not repairable. There are other issues like the stitches on the sofa, scars on the leather etc. I believe that Argos knows reports from this company really well as during his inspection he mentioned to me that he done some for claims against Argos and also he was never told by his customers that they were refused refund for his reports as the prices is excessive, so this is my another point when I will be claiming the monies back treat me the same way as they have done with others and don't discriminate me or my claim!!
  4. I had inspection today and the qualified independent upholster found more than one manufacturing fault, I am so happy with my choice of the company that performed the inspection, he looked all over the both sofas for 1,5 hrs and will provide me few pages long report in next 3-4 weeks. Apparently he provided reports for claims against Argos before so if they will try to say they will not refund full cost of the report I will ask why they discriminate my claim when they have refunded the others that have provided his reports and will open small claims if will be needed. In Castelan report they were saying that sofa was sticky and contaminated with head oil, he examined and there is no evidence of the contamination and in fact it is the sealant all over the sofas that has failed as they haven't sealed it properly so other areas will be peeling off as well. Common people, my post had over 600 views, please start posting on this thread your issues with sofas from Argos!!!
  5. Red face Castelan Furniture Reports - leather sofas Argos or any other retailer Hello, I have posted before about the problem with my 15 months old blistered leather sofa from Argos. Today I have managed to obtain copy of the report prepared by Castelan which states no manufacturer fault. Previously I was advise by CS team at Argos that report is saying that rub test was performed and explained to me that rub test :" In simple terms, a rub test is the application of heat on the fabric (in this case leather), to check the prominence of natural oils (headoil) in the fabric/material. The lack of these oil can cause the cracking/blistering or flaking of the material. As this was not found to be the case on your sofa, there is no manufacturing fault." Today I obtained a copy of the report from Argos which is saying: 3str LHF seat, is opposite TV, most used chair in the room, leather is dull+sticky to the touch (everywhere else on the suite is fine) damage across the leather has been caused by external contamination from the customers head overtime if covered and claim continues an attempt to clean, colour and re-seal the leather could be made 90mins with van stock I have questioned why I was provided different explanation by CS team and I am awaiting reply. I highlighted that that this sofa is not in front of the TV and is not the most used as it is the second sofa (2 seater) that is in front of TV and is mostly used, the inspected sofa was not dull and definitely was not sticky and there was no difference between other areas of the sofa. If it was head oil that caused the damage (in the e-mail from CS they claimed that lack of it cause the damage!) after 15 months of use clearly the sofa is not fit for purpose and the quality of the finish is poor. I know there was no contamination to the sofa to cause this and the report from Castelan has errors ie the sofa is not in front of TV etc. I will have independent inspection on 20th April and if it will prove my claim I will be reporting Castelan to Trading standards. I am looking for others that faced the same problem of inaccurate report from them and had an independent report that contradicted their findings so that I can support my complain to trading standarts and Argos itself. Thank you in advance!!!
  6. Hello, I have posted before about the problem with my 15 months old blistered leather sofa from Argos. Today I have managed to obtain copy of the report prepared by Castelan which states no manufacturer fault. Previously I was advise by CS team at Argos that report is saying that rub test was performed and explained to me that rub test :" In simple terms, a rub test is the application of heat on the fabric (in this case leather), to check the prominence of natural oils (headoil) in the fabric/material. The lack of these oil can cause the cracking/blistering or flaking of the material. As this was not found to be the case on your sofa, there is no manufacturing fault." Today I obtained a copy of the report from Argos which is saying: 3str LHF seat, is opposite TV, most used chair in the room, leather is dull+sticky to the touch (everywhere else on the suite is fine) damage across the leather has been caused by external contamination from the customers head overtime if covered and claim continues an attempt to clean, colour and re-seal the leather could be made 90mins with van stock I have questioned why I was provided different explanation by CS team and I am awaiting reply. I highlighted that that this sofa is not in front of the TV and is not the most used as it is the second sofa (2 seater) that is in front of TV and is mostly used, the inspected sofa was not dull and definitely was not sticky and there was no difference between other areas of the sofa. If it was head oil that caused the damage (in the e-mail from CS they claimed that lack of it cause the damage!) after 15 months of use clearly the sofa is not fit for purpose and the quality of the finish is poor. I know there was no contamination to the sofa to cause this and the report from Castelan has errors ie the sofa is not in front of TV etc. I will have independent inspection on 20th April and if it will prove my claim I will be reporting Castelan to Trading standards. I am looking for others that faced the same problem of inaccurate report from them and had an independent report that contradicted their findings so that I can support my complain to trading standarts and Argos itself. Thank you in advance!!!
  7. Thank you guys, I have my inspection date, the report will be written to court standard and the fee that I will be paying is still significantly below the max specified by court, so I should be fine with claiming the fee back from Argos, I know that retailer can't limit my choice of upholster and the cost associated with it. Will have report by the end of April hopefully!
  8. Cheers, they are not member of Furniture Ombudsman, however I have used now Resolver tool on MonaySavingexpert.com, Argos is part of it. I have put claim under the CRA and stated that my concerns about the report were not considered by Argos at all, requested letter of deadlock so that I can take the matter further. They replied and said if I can provide a report from independent qualified sofa specialist they will review it and reimburse the cost if he will find manufacturing fault. So I am waiting for the confirmation of availability of fully qualified upholster to attend the inspection, I wish they would actually care about the customer and use reputable company to do their warranty inspection. I hope the other person will get in touch so we can see if we have problem with the same sofa
  9. Hi I have the same problem with Argos, bought Hart of House Salsbury tan sofas, 100% "top"quality italian leather, delivered in december 2015, so only 15 months old. One of them blistered and peeled off on back rest, They sent castelan and told me that report proves that it is not manufacturing fault, I asked them to explain what the test was and this is what they said : " In simple terms, a rub test is the application of heat on the fabric (in this case leather), to check the prominence of natural oils (headoil) in the fabric/material. The lack of these oil can cause the cracking/blistering or flaking of the material. As this was not found to be the case on your sofa, there is no manufacturing fault.". I told them technician did not apply any heat on my damaged sofa, he only sprayed something and wiped it, that was all what he did, I also told him that I regularly apply leather protection cream on both sofas and only one has peeled off . I have send them letter under the Consumer act saying that the item is not satisfactory quality and they mislead me by selling them as "top quality", they still refure to pay for the repair. I am getting independent report from furniture reports £260, but worth it to take these sorry people to court. Please can you let me know if you have problem with the same sofa or any other Hart of house lether sofa? Many Thanks!!!
×
×
  • Create New...