T-Mobile Penalty Charge

ashette · 18th October 2006, 17:11

Hello, I wasn't sure where to post this but this is as good a place as any.

I recently had a bounced Direct Debit for my monthly T-Mobile phone bill and paid over the phone a couple of days after it bounced. Got this month's bill a couple of days ago and I'm apparently being charged £23.50 for an unpaid direct debit penalty charge! Not run into this sort of thing before with phone companies! I also got charged £3 for paying the balance over the phone, so have in effect been charged £26.50 by T-Mobile for the bounced direct debit (and will be charged on the bank's end too, boo!). Would the bank charge situation apply to a phone contract also?

livelylad · 18th October 2006, 17:18

Quote:

Originally Posted by ashette

Hello, I wasn't sure where to post this but this is as good a place as any.

I recently had a bounced Direct Debit for my monthly T-Mobile phone bill and paid over the phone a couple of days after it bounced. Got this month's bill a couple of days ago and I'm apparently being charged £23.50 for an unpaid direct debit penalty charge! Not run into this sort of thing before with phone companies! I also got charged £3 for paying the balance over the phone, so have in effect been charged £26.50 by T-Mobile for the bounced direct debit (and will be charged on the bank's end too, boo!). Would the bank charge situation apply to a phone contract also?

You can claim the £23.50 back, the £3 you can as they say its costs to cover the Admin for not paying by DD. Bollocks really

Movingon · 18th October 2006, 19:07

You can claim it all back. Follow a similar process to claiming back your bank charges

buzby · 21st October 2006, 15:57

Absolutely - the sooner these companies realise we're not going to tolerate this, they'll learn the hard way. Can I suggest you end ALL your direct debits and take responsibility for making these payments yourself? If your bank offers Home Banking, it's easy to arrange and the phone company whould be hard-pressed to prove that it cost them more to administer your account when you paid electronically, than when they just 'took' it"

feelingfine · 24th October 2006, 17:22

Hello, SORRY ASH TO HIJACK YOUR THREAD!
my wife got exactly the same letter and same cost,what should she do pay this bill minus the £23.50 or pay the full amount and then try to reclaim this £23.50.?

Would appreciate any help here, and ash sorry once again to hijack your thread!!! appologies mate

Movingon · 24th October 2006, 17:51

Your choice really... if you fail to pay it they will chase you, and may end up taking YOU to court - but it's only as scary as the other option; which is that you pay it and claim it back via the courts.

To be honest there is no real end-game disadvantage either way; you will end up getting back your money without it having any effect on your credit rating.

buzby · 24th October 2006, 18:32

Yup - do what you feel comfortable with. If you don't want to appear the baddie - pay the amound they request in full, then advise them due to the charges you regretfully will be cancelling your DD. THEN, yopu can advise them you will be making a claim against them for these unrealistic fees if they cannot provide a breakdown of costs.

kirstytwin · 25th October 2006, 21:03

I am in the same situation, I not only was charged £26.5 from T mobile but also £30 from my bank I have changed banks and phone service, just need to get the charges back now.

Kirsty

buzby · 25th October 2006, 21:55

Quote:

Originally Posted by kirstytwin

I am in the same situation, I not only was charged £26.5 from T mobile but also £30 from my bank I have changed banks and phone service, just need to get the charges back now.
Kirsty

Just get the ball rolling - we all had to start somewhere!

JDandCoke · 26th October 2006, 11:40

I have the same letter from t-mobile this morning

I ordered my The Lawpack Small Claims Kit the other day so I'll be getting all these charges back.

£23.50 for a payment failure charge! How can they justify it...

Movingon · 26th October 2006, 12:57

errr.... they can't - that's kinda the whole point?

ashette · 2nd November 2006, 16:27

I rang the customer services department about this who reckoned that the 23.50 was to cover the bank charging them for the Direct Debit which hadn't been paid. Anyone know if this is legitimate?

buzby · 2nd November 2006, 16:32

No. Ask to see their bank statement.

(Since they initiated the transfer, it's a bit strange why their bank would want to charge them for something they've done), after all YOUR bank could have charged you £30 for NOT paying it!

ashette · 2nd November 2006, 16:59

My bank ARE charging me for the failed DD, so I will have effectively paid £55 in charges when the original bill was £41.

What's especially galling is when I first set up the phone contract I requested a pay date after my monthly pay day so I wouldn't have this kind of problem, which they completely ignored and set the pay date to 3 days prior to that, when I have the least money. When I rang up to try to change it they told me I had to wait until after the first payment went through and of course I forgot to ring again to get it changed, being as I have a life outside waiting in call systems which I consider akin to having my fingernails pulled out one by one.

buzby · 2nd November 2006, 17:09

Absolutely - that's why it belies belief that you should have to pay T-Mobile's bank charges, after all they're not paying yours! You really need to get ALL these charges back, so explain to the bank that T-Mobile didn't take it out when thgey shoulkd have (gloss over the bit about the first payment needing to go through first). As a one off, they might waive it - if they stick their heels in, treat them with the same disrespect and demant repayment of all/any penalty charges levied previously. That'll teach 'em!

gmex2005 · 22nd November 2006, 12:41

I have also just been sent a bill with this ridiculous (and unlawful) charge on it as my DD bounced last month. I haven't had a chance to have another look through the contract I signed with them yet, but I wondered whether I could terminate the contract on the grounds that it does not comply with UK law. If anyone has any ideas I would be grateful!

buzby · 22nd November 2006, 12:58

No, you won't be able to repudiate your contract based on this alone. However, you can turn it to your advantage by writing to them and saying that you believe the fee charged is being used to 'fine' you, and this in itself can be challenged in the courts, as such, you call upon them to provide costings that the fee charged directly related to the rejection of their claim for payment. (You have paid them by other means, haven't you?). Explain that in view of their actions, you are unwilling to permit them to take funds from your account in the future, and the DDM is cancelled. (Make sure you tell you bank).

Also add in your letter you will arrange to pay their invoices on presentation directly via BACS (if you bank online this is a breeze) and ask for the account and sort number, along with any reference they require to be quoted with such payment. If they say there is an additional fee for not paying by DDM, say this fee will also be challenged, and to ensure it does not appear on your account. If the foregoing does not meet with their approval, you will agree to their closure of the account within the next 30 days with no penalties.

That should make them take you seriously!

CAG Products - We think that these will help you to make your claim or Reclaim your Right These sales also help us to keep helping YOU and keeps this site free of third party adverts!

Small Claims Kit	Small Claims Court Guide New Edition	CallBurner - Skype CallRecorder Review	Last Will & Testament Kit	Fight a Motoring Ticket

Alternatively you could purchase a CAG email address here, or maybe you'd prefer our address labels here
UPDATE: Consumer Forums ConsumerWiki is now LIVE - click here: ConsumerWiki N.B. Please note - due to postage costs these products are only available in the U.K.