Sony laptop woes **SORTED**

[David Horn]

Bit of a strange situation with a Sony laptop bought from Comet in July this year. It freezes randomly when playing games, showing an error message that says "Memory Parity Error - Contact your hardware vendor".

I called Sony, and they said that it's "a Windows thing", and since a memory testing program says the RAM is OK, won't look at it without charging me. Comet agree with Sony.

The manager of the store explained that the guarantee only covers the hardware; that this is a software problem, and that it is my responsibility to prove otherwise - despite the fact that a hardware specific error message is displayed on the screen when the laptop crashes!

I have no idea what to do now, because Comet delegate everything to Sony. The manager says he has no authority to offer a replacement now it's two months old, and that I should try to avoid playing games. Everyone higher up the line at Comet Customer Services agrees with him.

Any advice before I stick the thing on eBay and suck the £200 loss?

Cheers,

David.

Below is the text of a letter I sent to the MD last week, but I can't see there being much chance of a reply:

Dear Mr Harvey,

I purchased a Sony VAIO FZ11L from the Exeter Comet store in July for £799. One of the reasons I bought it was to run games, for which I chose, paid for, and expected a premium product.

Sadly, the computer has a hardware fault preventing it from running any demanding game successfully, with the machine freezing a random during play and requiring me to switch the computer off and on before I can use it again. As you can imagine, this is extremely frustrating.

Sony is unable to solve the problem over the phone and cannot advise further without inspecting the laptop, at which point they will charge me if a fault is not found. Given that it only occurs when playing games (and very occasionally at that), it seems likely that Sony will be unable to reproduce it. The manager of the Exeter store explained that your guarantee only covers the hardware, and not any software installed, and that it is my responsibility to prove otherwise - despite the fact that a hardware specific error message is displayed when the laptop crashes.

Regardless of where the problem lies, the point is that the computer is not doing what I bought it to do, and Sony accepts that as of this moment they don’t know how to fix it. Your store says that it is Sony’s responsibility, and the customer, me, is trapped in the middle with a computer that is not fit for its purpose and essentially useless for anything but browsing the internet, something a machine a quarter its price could do.

I chose to buy from you because I have, in the past, received exemplary customer care and support, and I am surprised to have been let down like this. I am more than happy to accept a replacement machine and am not pushing for a full refund.

I look forward to receiving a reply from you within the next 14 days. If not, I am afraid that I will have no choice but to take the issue to the Small Claims Court, as regretfully I cannot see any other solution.

Yours sincerely,

David Horn

[gyzmo]

Firstly, it is for Comet to sort this out as that is with whom you have a contract with, not Sony.

Secondly, within the first 6 months, the presumption is that the goods were faulty to begin with. It is down to the seller to prove otherwise.
How Sony can say that it is one thing without even looking at it is, frankly, a joke (bear in mind also my first sentence).

Thirdly, the guarantee is additional to your statutory rights, and does not replace them. In this case, you are seeking restitution as granted by Parliament, and not by what some company says it will do. The guarantee is irrelevant in this case.

I would go back to the shop and quote SoGA - goods must be of satisfactory quality and as described - and tell them to sort it. You are entitled to a repair, replacement or (partial) refund - whichever is the most cost effective and convenient (it is for Comet to chose which).

[David Horn]

Hi Gyzmo,

There-in lies the problem! The crash only occurs when playing games and memory tests come back clean. Comet will send it off to Sony for inspection; Sony will say that it's software-related because they're hardly likely to spend several hours playing games on it, and then I have to pay the inspection bill, likely to be over £100.

This is the real issue, unfortunately, as regardless of whether it's hardware or software, the responsibility is on me to prove that the problem is inherent in the laptop, at my expense.

Thanks,

David.

[mr elmo]

Hi

Have you ran this memory testing program? Memtest86+ - Advanced Memory Diagnostic Tool if you run that and it shows a fault then sony/comets tech support should listen, just make a note of the fault message

[David Horn]

Hello there,

I have run MemTest86 repeatedly. It shows no problem, but it can't test video card memory. If I send the computer in, Sony will run their equivalent test and assume it's a software fault.

Thanks,

David.

[Bookworm]

Originally Posted by David Horn

Hi Gyzmo,

There-in lies the problem! The crash only occurs when playing games and memory tests come back clean. Comet will send it off to Sony for inspection; Sony will say that it's software-related because they're hardly likely to spend several hours playing games on it, and then I have to pay the inspection bill, likely to be over £100.

This is the real issue, unfortunately, as regardless of whether it's hardware or software, the responsibility is on me to prove that the problem is inherent in the laptop, at my expense.

Thanks,

David.

No, it isn't, and you are not listening to what Gyzmo said:

Within the first 6 months of purchase, it is up to them to prove that it is isn't faulty, NOT for you to prove it is. Nor can they make you pay for the tests and/or repairs. However, with the clock ticking on the 6 months, I would hurry up if I were you.

[gyzmo]

The guarntee may contain such a clause as o paying costs, but you are claiming a statutory right. Listen to Bookworm too!

[David Horn]

Hi Bookworm,

I do see where you're coming from, but if the laptop passes Sony's own tests, surely that would be more than enough to counter my evidence that it is faulty? On top of this, Comet obviously believe that Sony is entitled to charge, and if Sony decide that I ought to pay, they have my laptop as an excellent bargaining chip.

[gyzmo]

Why not take the laptop AND the game (or several) to the store - they can't turn round and say that all the games are faulty. And the costs bit again does not matter. Sony can charge Comet if they want - that is between them and nothing to do with you.

[David Horn]

Hiya Gyzmo,

Been there, done that, I'm afraid! The manager and staff just said that they weren't qualified engineers and so couldn't comment on the situation.

[patdavies]

What operating system?
What game(s)?
Do(es) the game(s) use Direct X to access video memory
What is the complete error message? Is there any code with it?

[David Horn]

Hi there,

Happens on Sony's OEM version of Vista Home Premium and my university copy of Vista Ultimate. Haven't tried XP because it needs a floppy drive to load the SATA drivers.

The games it's most prevalent in are Microsoft Flight Simulator X (which I use a fair amount because I'm working my way towards an ATPL), and Bioshock. Doesn't happen in Worms Armageddon, but it's a 5 year old game. I haven't got any newer games to try, but I'll hunt out some demos on the internet later. 3DMark2005 runs through correctly, but at times you can play for hours and hours before it'll crash.

I believe that the games do indeed use DirectX, but I've downloaded the latest version for Bioshock, and it crashes regardless of whether Bioshock is set to run in DX9 or DX10 mode.

There is no error code given. The full message is:

*** Hardware Malfunction
Call your hardware vendor for support
NMI. Parity Check / Memory Parity Error
*** The system has halted ***

Sometimes the writing on the blue screen is corrupted, and sometimes it freezes up and never gets to the blue screen.

[gyzmo]

Originally Posted by David Horn

Hiya Gyzmo,

Been there, done that, I'm afraid! The manager and staff just said that they weren't qualified engineers and so couldn't comment on the situation.

No one is expecting them to be so, but it is still their obligation to sot it (using a third party if necessary). Saying "we don't know" is not an acceptable response.

[David Horn]

No one is expecting them to be so, but it is still their obligation to sot it (using a third party if necessary). Saying "we don't know" is not an acceptable response.

I quite agree, but do you see the situation they've put me in? They are prepared to send it off to Sony on the basis that I will pay if Sony decide it's a Vista issue. The manager will not budge on this issue, and says the buck stops with him.

Three possible scenarios now present:

1) I send it off and it comes back fixed. Unlikely, I think, given that it passes memory tests.

2) I send it off, Sony send me a bill, and I have to pay it to get the computer back. ~£100 out of pocket.

3) I send it off, refuse to pay, and Sony refuses to give the computer back to Comet. With no support from the company, I really do not see any options open to me.

I would love to go down and just get involved in a shouting match, but it comes down to the fact that I either end up without a computer, or £100 down. It is very easy to say that Comet has these obligations, but if they simply choose to ignore them what is one to do?

I really do appreciate all the advice given here, but reading through the archives in the Comet forum reveals one, perhaps two threads where someone has been successful against them.

That's why I think the best option is to simply eBay the thing and be rid of it. At least I can honestly say it's in perfect condition...

[kabukiman]

Heat is main problem with laptops and gaming intensifies this, unless its specifically made for gaming jet engine fans are not installed as standard.
Probably there lies your problem, memory gets overheated, errors start to appear.
Hardware and software problems , but who to blame?

[David Horn]

This is why the problem is so frustrating... I'm 99.9% certain that it's not heat related, since it can sometimes happen within 5 minutes of starting the computer up from cold and loading the game.

[Bookworm]

If they do either of these things, you get Trading Standards on their backsides.

I am not sure how much clearer any of us can make it: These are your STATUTORY rights, they can not simply pass the buck.

I can also tell you that if you try to flog it on ebay and the buyer gets the same issue, you are opening a whole new can of worms for yourself.

Ultimately, it is your choice, we have given you all the advice we can as regards your rights, what you do next is up to you.